Neurodiversity
Social skills programmes for autistic children have good intentions. Many have poor outcomes. Here is why the social scripts approach is being reconsidered, and what neurodiversity-affirming social support actually looks like.
Social skills training has been a core component of autism intervention for decades. The premise seems reasonable: autistic people often struggle with neurotypical social interaction, so teaching the rules and scripts of neurotypical social interaction should help. The research on outcomes, however, tells a more complicated story, and the autistic community's own perspective on being taught to perform social scripts is worth taking seriously.
The difference between social skills and social scripts
Social skills refer to the underlying capacities for social connection: understanding others' emotional states, communicating clearly, navigating conflict, building and maintaining relationships. These are genuine skills that can be developed and are worth supporting.
Social scripts are the specific learned behaviours that are taught in most social skills programmes: make eye contact, greet people with your name and a question about them, mirror the other person's body language. These are neurotypical social conventions, and teaching autistic people to perform them is training in masking, the effortful performance of neurotypicality, not in genuine social connection.
Why scripts don't generalise
The most consistent finding in research on social skills programmes for autistic people is that the skills taught in the programme do not reliably transfer to real-world social situations. An autistic person can learn to perform the greeting script in a therapy room and still not know how to apply it in a new social context, because the script, not the underlying social understanding, was what was learned.
This is not a failure of the autistic person. It is a limitation of the approach. Neurotypical social interaction is contextually complex and constantly shifting. Scripts are, by definition, fixed. Teaching fixed scripts for a fluid system produces exactly the generalisation failure that the research consistently finds.
“Teaching an autistic person social scripts trains them in masking, not in connection. The two are not the same thing, and the research on outcomes reflects that difference.”
What neurodiversity-affirming social support looks like
Rather than teaching autistic people to perform neurotypical social behaviour, neurodiversity-affirming approaches focus on: building genuine social understanding, supporting the autistic person in finding social environments and interactions that work for their profile, developing communication in ways that are authentic to the individual, and where needed, providing explicit explanations of social contexts rather than scripts.
- Explicit education about how and why social interactions work, not scripts to follow but understanding of the purposes and patterns of social interaction
- Interest-based connection: finding other people who share genuine interests creates social connection that does not require masking
- Autistic social norms are valid: autistic people, with other autistic people, often develop different but equally meaningful social patterns. These do not need to be corrected toward neurotypical norms
- Communication support for genuine expression: supporting the autistic person to communicate what they actually think and feel, in the way that works for them, rather than training them to communicate in neurotypical ways
- Social understanding work: theory of mind development, understanding others' emotional states, conflict resolution, genuine skills with broad application
What parents can do
If your child is in a social skills programme, ask your provider what the evidence base is for generalisation of the skills being taught. Ask how success is measured. Ask whether the programme takes an affirming approach to autistic communication styles or aims to normalise them.
And consider prioritising authentic connection over performed connection. A child with one or two genuine relationships, people who accept them as they are, will fare better socially over time than a child who has learned to perform dozens of social scripts in settings where they feel they cannot be themselves.
Neurodiversity
A note on accuracy:While every effort has been made to ensure the information in this article is accurate at the time of writing, facts, policies and research can change. We're human, and sometimes we get things wrong. If you spot something that needs updating, we'd genuinely love to hear from you.
Newsletter
Worth reading. Not often.
Practical guides on neurodiversity, NDIS navigation, and Australian schools. Sent when there's something worth saying, not on a schedule for the sake of it.
No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
Dave Harrison
ESW · Neurodiversity Advocate · Podcast Host
Dave Harrison is currently working in Australian schools as an Education Support Worker. He's the founder of THRVHUB, host of the Different Is Normal podcast, and a parent of a neurodivergent teenager, writing from both sides of the classroom.
More about DaveMore to read
Comments
Sign in with GitHub to leave a comment. All comments are moderated through GitHub Discussions: respectful and on-topic only.